"Traditional Logic is a wonderful course! ...Traditional Logic, Book I by Martin Cothran is the most helpful logic course
out there today." "The
subjects covered have some overlap with Introductory Logic by Douglas Wilson. I believe Traditional Logic, Book I is a more basic
course and explains things that Introductory Logic leaves out
or assumes you know, or explains poorly. Introductory Logic covers
some topics not touched on in Traditional Logic. Where the two
overlap, I believe Traditional Logic to do a superior job in presenting
the material."
- Christine
Miller, CCH Classical Christian Homeschooling (ClassicalHomeschooling.org) read
full review here
"This
is the best exposition of Aristotelian logic I have yet seen aimed
at homeschoolers. Easier to follow than Gordon Clark's logic text,
more comprehensive (though less mathematical) than Canon Press'
Introductory Logic, and easy on the eyes with its wide margins
and visual diagrams, this course deserves a place in many homeschools."
- Mary
Pride, Big Book of Home Learning
"After
grammar, I recommend learning traditional, Aristotelian logic.
Right now, the best course out there to learn this is Martin Cothran's
Traditional Logic (in two texts), from Memoria Press."
- Lene
Jaqua, Classical Writing
With
about five pages of teaching material per lesson, the author has
broken each concept into bite-size chunks that are
meaty without being overwhelming. Each chapter is well organized
with an introduction, section headings, and a conclusion summarizing
the lesson--which serves as a great place for the student to
refer to when needing a quick review. One of the most helpful aspects
of this text is the provision of wide margins, where the student
will find important points from each page restated. This aids
greatly in the understanding of the concepts being taught. Although
such an in-depth study as the one presented in Traditional Logic could easily become dry and tedious, the author appeals to young
people with interesting examples and a personable writing style...
In doing this review, I did quite a bit of reading about logic
programs available to homeschoolers. (I narrowed my research to
those that teach formal logic, rather than informal or modern
logic.) As I looked through some of the other resources available,
Traditional Logic stood out from the rest with its clear, orderly
presentation of the topic and the important student exercises
that cement and clarify understanding. As a reviewer, I get to
look at lots of curricula--some are unfamiliar to me, but they
do cover subjects that I have taught or been exposed to in my
own educational background. With no experience regarding the study
of logic, the idea of reviewing this course was intimidating!
Due mostly to Mr. Cothran's excellent treatment of the subject
and the step-by-step process by which students (including myself)
are led, I found myself beginning to be comfortable with formal
logic and even brave enough to consider using this course with
my own children.
Making the grade: A
- Cindy
Prechtel, Editor, Homeschool Reviews for You. read
full review here.
"I
taught a co-op using Martin Cothran's Traditional Logic I, and
it worked great. It can be done very easily as self-taught. It
tends to be repetitive in its exercises (Saxon-ish), but the kids
all learned it without any problems. Then my son did Book II on
his own. Book II is much more challenging than Book I, but he
had no problems. It is a very clear book."
- M.A.
"I
am currently using Latina Christiana II with three of my children
and finishing up Traditional Logic II in a very small 'class'
setting. I have been very impressed with the quality of these
materials and how easy they have made it to teach the trivium
tools.... Having used almost every other logic curriculum available
to homeschoolers, I now fervently recommend TL to CCE parents."
-T.M.,
New Mexico (teaching 7 children, congratulations)
"I'll
put in a plug for Traditional Logic. My daughter and I are going
through Book I together and it is going very well! The book has
daily exercises which are short. The material in each chapter
is clearly presented. I am very happy with it."
- B.,
NY
"My
13-year-old loved [Traditional Logic I] this year (we plan on
buying the next year's TL II soon). He thought it was very interesting
and pretty much worked on his own. We had some really interesting
discussions during it and he has been able to relate things learned
to other courses."
- M.,
Vegsource.com
"The
book by Martin Cothran follows a systematic approach for in-depth
study of logic. From seventh grade through adult, this conversational
text is well-written and designed for the teacher or parent with
no logic background. Count me in!"
- Judy
McAdoo, Homeschooling Today
"Recommendation:
Introduction to Formal Logic addresses a subject
unfamiliar to many in a straightforward, understandable way. The
wide margins and visually appealing format keep the reader from
becoming overwhelmed, and the exercises reduce intimidation by
providing plenty of reinforcement. An understanding of basic formal
logic should be within reach of all students and their parents
with the use of this program."
- Martha
R. HomeschoolChristian.com
"A
really terrific text. The material is handled very clearly
and in digestible chunks. I am using the text in a Sunday
School setting and am having good results."
- Rev.
K.S., New York, NY
"This
book is an excellent learning tool for any logic class. I am one
of the few who have been through this book being taught by Martin
Cothran himself. His ideas and methods of teaching in this book
are easy to follow and comprehend, and his approach to teaching
logic is unique and refreshing. "
- J.W.,
Lexington, KY
"I
teach at our high school enrichment classes, and I use Traditional
Logic by Cothran (memoriapress.com). I love his style. I like
the way it is formatted *for* homeschoolers and not traditional
institutional classes. The text is broken into manageable *daily*
parts. It tends to be repetitious, but all of my students have
done well with it. The first book is definitely a one-semester class.
The second book takes longer, if done well. It did not require
any video or extra material. I think I pulled a college logic
book out, but basically everything is contained in the student's
book. I think any student could teach themselves using it alone."
- M.A.,
homeschool teacher
"I
teach an eighth grade logic class using Martin Cothran's Traditional
Logic series, which I prefer to Mr. Wilson's text. I find that
it is, in the end, clear and easier to use."
- R. Durham, NC
"Traditional
Logic from Memoria Press was a big hit with my daughter. It lays
a great foundation for Classical Rhetoric for the Modern Student."
- S., VegSource.com
"HOW
TO THINK
Memoria Press’ renowned Latin program, Latina Christiana,
is now joined by their new course, Traditional Logic. Author Martin
Cothran gives a straightforward presentation of traditional principles
of logic, such as would have been taught in Catholic educational
institutions from the early Middle Ages until about the 1960s.
Students learn the mental steps involved in logical thinking
and are taught to identify the common errors in reasoning which
lead to faulty conclusions. The program is geared for high schoolers,
but an interested middle school student could probably follow
it. Because of the density of the material, this is probably a
once or twice a week subject, leaving ample time for the information
to sink in. It might also be a fun subject for a dad to teach
the older kids (or even a group of teenagers in the local support
group) on Saturdays."
- Reviewed
by Lesley Payne, Resource Reviews
"Traditional Logic is a recommended resource by the National Christian
Forensics and Communication Association."
- http://www.ncfca.org/Pages/Resources/bookmaterials.html
"This book has been prepared with homeschoolers in mind, although
it could readily be used in a private school setting. The material
is presented in easily understood increments with lots of practice
and exercises to reinforce what the student is learning. The answer
key is very helpful for the parent/teacher as it includes the
answers to all exercises. A highly recommended resource!"
- Tree
of Life http://www.treeoflifeathome.com/logic.htm
"Just to let you know, my husband loves teaching Latin and logic with your curriculum. He never studied them himself until teaching our children and really enjoys it."
- D.A., NC